Cart
0
Your mascara isn't the problem. Your eyeliner probably isn't either. The real culprit behind that mid-afternoon smudge is almost always the order you're applying things — and once you fix that, a five-minute eye routine can genuinely hold up all day.
Why Liner Goes First
Most people apply mascara, then try to tighten the line with eyeliner after. That's backwards. When you line first, you set the shape of the eye before any mascara is on the lashes. If you smudge the liner slightly while applying mascara, you can clean it up without disturbing a single lash.
The CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Charcoal is built for this step. It's a slim retractable pencil — no sharpening needed. The charcoal shade is softer than pure black, which reads as polished rather than harsh and is far more forgiving if your hand isn't perfectly steady first thing in the morning. Draw along the upper lash line in short strokes from inner to outer corner, then let it sit for about thirty seconds before moving on. That brief pause helps it anchor to the lid.
Pick the Right Mascara for Your Lashes
You don't need three mascaras. You need to know what your lashes actually need today.
- CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara in Very Black — best for sparse or fine lashes. The wide brush deposits a lot of product in a single pass for a bold, full result.
- CoverGirl Professional 3-in-1 Mascara — best for length and separation. Its brush keeps lashes distinct rather than clumped, for a cleaner, more defined finish.
- CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara in Very Black — the heaviest formula of the group, built for maximum volume and definition together. Reach for this one when you want the mascara to do most of the talking.
- CoverGirl Professional Mascara Regular Brush in Very Black 200 — the reliable everyday option. Consistent coverage, works on most lash types, no decisions required.
The Full 5-Minute Sequence
- Line first. Apply the CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus in Charcoal along the upper lash line, close to the roots, using short strokes.
- Let it set. About thirty seconds — do your brows or apply lip balm while you wait.
- Apply mascara. Choose based on the day. Wiggle the wand at the roots, then pull upward.
- Touch up the liner. Now that mascara is on, check the line. Clean up any gaps in seconds — no mascara to disturb.
- Done.
One Honest Trade-Off
Pencil liners, including the Perfect Point Plus, aren't waterproof in the way a gel liner is. For a standard workday or a full day out, the charcoal shade helps — light smudging on grey is far less noticeable than on black. If you're heading straight from the office to dinner, a quick re-line takes under a minute. This routine is fast and effective for everyday wear, not indestructible.
Pick up the CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner and whichever mascara fits your lash goals at feelforever21.com — and if it's your first order, use code WELCOME5 for 5% off. Free shipping across the USA too.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does it matter if I apply mascara before or after eyeliner?
Yes — and it matters more than most people realize. Applying liner first lets you set the shape of your eye before any mascara is on the lashes. If you smudge the liner slightly while applying mascara, you can correct it without touching the lashes. Doing it the other way around usually means wiping mascara off your lid every time you try to fix the line.
Which CoverGirl mascara is best for adding volume to thin lashes?
The CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara is designed specifically for volume — its wide brush deposits a generous amount of product in a single pass, making thin or sparse lashes look noticeably fuller. If you want separation and definition instead, the CoverGirl Professional 3-in-1 is a better fit.
Why does my eyeliner smudge by midday even when I apply it carefully?
The most common reason is applying liner over or after other products — especially mascara or eyeshadow — so it never fully adheres to the lid. Applying liner directly to clean skin first, then letting it sit briefly before layering anything else, gives it the best chance to stay put. Oily lids can also be a factor; a light dusting of translucent powder over the liner after it sets can help lock it in place.
Is charcoal eyeliner a good choice for everyday wear, or is it too dark?
Charcoal is actually one of the most wearable everyday liner shades. It defines the eye clearly without the sharpness of pure black, which makes it more forgiving if the line isn't perfectly even. It works on most skin tones and reads as polished rather than dramatic — a solid choice if you want definition without a heavy look.
